Saturday, 28 June 2014

Seriously, What Is Forgiveness?

Text: Mark 2:1-12
Forgiveness is a common word in our faith vocabulary much like the words grace, faith, truth, love, and even the word God.  These words reflect foundational elements in our faith yet I think we readily use them without really knowing about what they mean.  This morning I want to look at what we mean by forgiveness because I think what we think we mean by it isn't exactly what we find in the Bible.
So what do we mean by forgiveness?  In the last 25 or so years something called forgiveness has made its way into the world of emotional therapy and healthy lifestyles.  Several studies were done that demonstrated that forgiving can contribute to our being happier and healthier whereas not forgiving and bearing a grudge can do the opposite.  So, it seems that there is something cathartic or soul cleansing about forgiving.  This is why if you look the word up in a more recent dictionary you will find that the subject of feelings comes up.  Forgiveness gets defined as a process one goes through in order to stop feeling anger or resentment towards another or to stop feeling like you need some sort of retribution for a wrong done to you.  You've heard people say, "Just let it go."  Definitions also involve ceasing to require the repayment of debt.
When looking up what it means to forgive in older dictionaries you often find the topic of pardon, to grant pardon to one who has wronged you, to let them go without exacting punishment.  There's also the financial side of things too.  There's also the idea of granting or allowing.  If you go way back to the Old English roots of "forgive" or "forgiefan" it means "to give in marriage".  Thus, it goes without saying that forgiveness and marriage go hand in hand.  The word essentially means "to give completely".  It is the act of giving with a huge sense of finality to it.  You can apply that to wrongdoings, to debts, and so on.  It is to relinquish a rightful claim to something forever, to utterly give it up. 
If I were to philosophize on this a bit I would say that forgiveness and trust go hand in hand.  When a father gave his daughter's hand in marriage it wasn't just an exchange of property as some want to see it.  He was letting go of any claim he had to rightfully be the one who provided for and protected his daughter and in turn completely trust another man and his family with that task.  When somebody wronged another, they in essence broke trust with that person and with the clan.  Therefore, to forgive was to give trust back to the offender.  Forgiveness led to reconciliation not only with the one offended but also with the whole clan.
Summing this up, our modern idea of forgiveness has to do with the cathartic process of letting go of anger and resentment.  The Old English roots of the word, which goes back to just before the 1100's have to do with maintaining trust in communities of people.  There is a bit of a narcissistic flip.  Today, forgiveness deals with me and how I feel.  Back, forgiveness dealt with us and how we trust each other.  Keep this in mind and let's move on to the Bible.
Looking at the Bible, when the word forgiveness comes up it is usually associated with the forgiveness of sins and therefore involves our relationship with God and with one another.   This comes out in the Lord's Prayer when we say forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors.  Also in our passage from Mark when Jesus said, "Son, your sins are forgiven" and then the Pharisees got upset because Jesus was doing something only God can do.  There is also our reading from the Psalms this morning, Psalm 32 begins, "Blessed (or happy) is the one whose transgression is forgiven, whose sin is covered."   We can see here an added dimension of our own need to be forgiven not just to forgive.
To get our English translations of the Bible we have to find words in our language that carry the same or similar meaning as the words in Greek or Hebrew.  This is rarely an exact science and it quite often happens that essential meaning gets lost or corrupted as the meanings of words change over time.  A long time ago the church began to use the Old English word "forgiefan" to translate into English a Latin not a Greek version of the Bible.  The Latin word they were trying to translate was perdonare, which means to pardon.  This had the unfortunate side effect of getting the church to think of sins being a ledger of offences for which we are guilty rather than as a disease in our humanity that causes a breakdown in our relationships with God and one another and destroys our God-given dignity as persons and rather makes us ashamed.
The Greek word Jesus uses which we translate as forgiven does not mean a cathartic process of doing away with anger and resentment nor does it mean pardoning a person of a ledger of offences.  The word is "aphiemi" and it simply means "to send away".  Once a year the ancient Israelites had a particular day for dealing with the sins of the people, Yom Kippur - the Day of Atonement.  It involved sacrificing a bull and two goats.  One of the goats was called the scapegoat.  It was called this because the priest would lay his hand upon its head and whisper the sins of the people into its ear and then it was led away into the wilderness where it was then sent away where it could be destroyed by whatever.  When Jesus told the man his sins were forgiven he meant sent away as in scapegoated out of existence.  This is of course pointing to Jesus' death on the cross.
That Greek word "aphiemi" (to send away) is the word that the Jews in Jesus' day were using to translate a particular Hebrew word, which we also translate as forgive.  The Hebrew word is nasah and it means to lift up and carry.  Think scapegoat as well.  The scapegoat carries away the sin of the people.  Our sin is carried away.  I like to think NASA and the space shuttle.  The Psalmist also uses a word, which means covered.  This refers also to the Day of Atonement.  A bull and a goat were killed and their blood, which represented their life, was taken.  The blood now represented life that had passed through death.  The high priest sprinkled it all over the temple and the priests and even the ark of the covenant to do two things: to cover over or cleanse the stain of sin on the people and the temple and to unite God and his people in the blood, this life that had passed through death.  This is why the Psalmist says blessed is the one whose sin is covered over.  This sprinkling of blood of course points us to Jesus death and resurrection and our union with him in the Holy Spirit.
So, with all that in mind what was Jesus telling this paralytic when he said! "Son, your sins are forgiven".  Was he saying that God had gone through a process to cathart his anger at the man or that God now trusts him again?  I don't think so.  Jesus said this when he saw the faith or faithfulness or loyalty of the four men.  They had lifted up and were carrying the paralytic on his mat to bring him to Jesus.  Jesus saw that they were nasah-ing this man and moreover removing every obstacle to bring him to Jesus where they knew he could be healed.  This compassionate act by faithful, loyal friends of carrying or nasah-ing this paralytic to Jesus is why Jesus says to the man that his sins are sent away.  This fellowship of friends were showing this paralytic unconditional love and acceptance by lifting him up and carrying him, bringing him to Jesus to be healed and removing every obstacle on the way.  Remember paralytics were viewed in the same way as lepers and blind people back then.  They were called unclean and cast out of the community because people believed them to be cursed by God for some horrible hidden sin that he or his parents had committed.  People would even refuse to touch them for fear of becoming unclean themselves.  Yet, here were these four men carrying this paralytic on the mat of his disease to Jesus and willingly taking his uncleanness upon themselves because they knew Jesus could and would heal the man.  Jesus saw their unconditional love in action and that's why he said, "Son (meaning you're one of my people), your sins are forgiven."  Whatever was keeping this man cut off from loving community was obviously gone, sent away by these four men lifting him up and carrying him.
So, seriously, what is forgiveness as far as the Bible is concerned?  It is not the cathartic process of letting go of anger and resentment.  It is not pardoning a person of their ledger of offences.  Forgiveness is what happens when a small group of people unconditionally love and accept a sin-sick person, bearing with him in all his weaknesses, bringing him to Jesus, removing all obstacles on the way so that he may know unconditional love and acceptance in Jesus name so that he is no longer outcast (though he may have deserved it).  Small groups of Jesus' people unconditionally welcoming and loving others in their brokenness and helping them to find wholeness in Jesus is what forgiveness is.  If there is a cathartic process of letting go of resentments, it is found while being nasah-ed by faithful Jesus people.  If there is such a thing as having the ledger wiped clean, it is found in the unconditional acceptance of faithful Jesus people.  Welcoming people into community where the unconditional love of Jesus rules the day and helping them to find peace in him is true forgiveness.  So let our way be the way of those four unnamed men.  Amen.